In the year 858 a queen in northern Europe was accused of sleeping with her own brother. She was accused of something worse as well, a crime so shameful that the court would not name it plainly. Her husband, King Lothair II, had a mistress he preferred and a son by her. He needed his wife out of the way, and the charge of incest was the quickest way to do it.
Queen Theutberga did what accused people did in that century. She submitted to a trial by ordeal. A man chosen to stand in for her plunged his arm into a cauldron of boiling water and pulled out a stone. His arm came out unharmed, and the court was supposed to treat that as God's verdict. The king and his bishops went on to ignore it. They pressured her until she signed a confession. They shut her in a convent and married the mistress.
Nobody in the Frankish world could stop Lothair. The bishops who might have done it depended on him. His brother the emperor had his own ambitions. Her only appeal was to one old city on the Tiber, where a man in his late fifties had just been made pope.
Nicholas I is the saint for people who have been overruled by someone more powerful. He is also for those who have been told that a settled matter is closed. He is for anyone who has been pushed to say something they do not mean, and for anyone who has been asked to keep quiet because the right person is on the wrong side. He was not gentle, and he was often not diplomatic. He was stubborn about the weak and unafraid of the strong, and that earned him the title the Great.
A Roman Boy in a City That Had Been Robbed
Nicholas was born in Rome around the year 800. His father, Theodore, held a respectable office in the city's administration. The family was Roman through and through, not part of the Frankish aristocracy that was starting to dominate the Church in the West.
Rome in his boyhood was a wounded city. On Christmas Day of the year 800, Pope Leo III had crowned Charlemagne emperor, and the old claim that Rome stood at the center of a united Christian world was suddenly alive again. By the time Nicholas was grown, Charlemagne's empire had split. His grandsons divided it after a bitter war. Kings and sub-kings competed for land, for loyalty, and for the blessing of bishops.
In 846 Arab raiders from North Africa sailed up the Tiber and attacked the basilicas of Saint Peter and Saint Paul, which stood outside the city walls. They stripped them of treasure. Nicholas was a young man then, perhaps in his forties by the time Pope Leo IV finished walling the Vatican hill. He had watched the Church's holiest places lie exposed, and he had watched a pope act to protect them.
The Deacon Who Learned How the Machine Worked
Nicholas rose through the clergy of Rome, serving as a subdeacon and then a deacon under successive popes. He was learned, disciplined, and widely respected. One of his later critics, writing a generation after his death, admitted that Nicholas combined humility with an unusual presence. He was tall, a good speaker, and generous to the poor.
He also became a trusted adviser to Pope Benedict III. This is the period that formed him. In 855 the Roman clergy elected Benedict, but an imperial faction pushed a rival, Anastasius, into the Lateran. Benedict was seized, abused, and held captive until the people of Rome rebelled and he was restored. Nicholas had watched, from inside the papal household, how kings and their agents tried to pick popes.
When Benedict died in April 858, Emperor Louis II was in Rome. Nicholas was elected and consecrated on April 24. As he rode to the Lateran, Louis walked beside his horse and held the bridle, the way a groom would. It was a gesture of respect, and the new pope noticed what it was worth. Within a few years he would find out whether the emperor's respect extended to obeying him.
The Winter the Emperor Came for Rome
The test began with Queen Theutberga's case and ended up at Rome's own gates.
Her husband's bishops held a council at Aachen in 860, then another in 862. They declared the marriage ended and approved a new one. Theutberga had been pushed into a confession and sent to a convent. Nicholas had received her appeal, and he refused to accept the verdict. He sent legates, two bishops, to a council at Metz in 863 to review the case. The council was meant to be fair. It was not. The legates sided with the king and accepted what looked like bribes. The archbishops of Cologne and Trier, Gunther and Thietgaud, rushed the result to Rome as a settled fact.
Nicholas could have accepted it. A cautious pope might have called it a pastoral compromise and hoped the problem went away. Instead he called a council at the Lateran in October 863 and cancelled the decisions made at Metz. He stripped Gunther and Thietgaud of their offices. He disciplined his own legates. His reasoning was simple, and it came from the words of Christ in the Gospel of Matthew, "what God has joined together, let no man separate." A marriage was not the king's to dissolve, and a confession wrung out of a frightened woman was not proof of anything.
The archbishops did not take it quietly. Early in 864 Gunther and Thietgaud came to Rome, backed by Emperor Louis II and his troops, who were more than willing to put pressure on the pope. Contemporary accounts say that Gunther's armed supporters threatened the clergy at Saint Peter's. Nicholas took refuge in the basilica. He fasted and prayed for two days with almost nothing to eat. The Roman clergy and people joined him in procession and penance. Then Louis fell ill with a fever, and his men were shaken. The emperor withdrew.
Nicholas never claimed this as a victory. The deposed archbishops stayed deposed, and Rome's authority stood, but the king was still the king.
What the Chair of Peter Meant to Him
The sources do not give us a private diary or a dramatic conversion. Nicholas was not a sinner who turned back to God in a famous moment. His vocation comes through in what he did with the office and in what he refused to let it become.
He believed what the Fathers of the Church had taught about Rome. Christ had said to Peter, "You are Peter, and on this rock I will build my Church" (Matthew 16:18). He had told him, "Feed my sheep" (John 21:17), and "Strengthen your brothers" (Luke 22:32). Pope Leo the Great, Pope Gelasius, and Pope Gregory the Great had all said, in their own centuries, that Peter's successor had a unique responsibility for the unity of the Church. Nicholas applied those teachings fully. A bishop wrongly deposed by his own colleagues could appeal to Rome. So could a queen. A pope's decision was to be heard, not reviewed by the king.
Some of the collections of church law circulating in Nicholas's day included texts that later scholars showed were forged. Nicholas drew on the Church's genuine inheritance, including the early canons that allowed appeals to Rome and the teachings of earlier popes, and his claims rested on those older foundations. His enemies called him ambitious. His defenders said that the Church was the only institution in Europe that could protect people from the powerful, and that someone had to say so out loud.
A Court of Appeal for the Powerless
Marriage. Nicholas made a lasting contribution to the Church's teaching on marriage. In his letters he held that a marriage rests on the free consent of the two people involved. Ceremony, dowry, and celebration mattered, but without consent they could not make a marriage. This protected women who were being pushed into unions and men who were being pushed out of them. When a Frankish noblewoman named Engeltrude walked out on her husband for another man, he held her accountable. When a king's daughter, Judith, eloped with a count, he urged her father to reconcile once he saw the marriage had been freely entered. He did not want rank to override consent in either direction.
The Bulgarians. In 864 or 865 Khan Boris of Bulgaria accepted baptism. He asked Rome for guidance, and he sent over a list of questions about Christian life, more than a hundred of them. Nicholas answered in 866. His replies are among the most humane documents of the century. Boris had asked whether torture could be used to get confessions out of suspected thieves, and Nicholas said no: confession must be freely given, and a Christian ruler could not extract it by force. He told Boris that new converts should be taught, not coerced. He treated questions about diet, clothing, and local customs patiently, saying that many were matters of habit and not of faith. He sent bishops to instruct the Bulgarians, including Formosus of Porto, who would later become pope himself.
Bishops and the Roman poor. When Archbishop Hincmar of Reims and his synod deposed Rothad of Soissons, Rothad appealed to Rome and spent years in confinement for it. Nicholas took up his case and, in 865, had him restored. Hincmar was the greatest churchman in the Frankish world, and he gave in. In Italy, Archbishop John of Ravenna tried to put himself beyond Rome's reach. Nicholas summoned him, excommunicated him when he refused, and had him back in line by 861. And in Rome itself he cared for the poor. The accounts of his pontificate say that he fed them regularly, welcomed pilgrims, and gave away money freely.
When the East Pushed Back, and the King Would Not Bend
His hardest opposition came from two directions.
Constantinople. In 858 Emperor Michael III forced Patriarch Ignatius out of office and put Photius in his place. Photius was a brilliant scholar, but he was a layman who had been ordained through every clerical rank in about six days. Nicholas sent legates to look into the matter. They allowed themselves to be swayed. In 863 he cancelled what they had done, declared Photius deposed, and stated that Ignatius was the rightful patriarch.
Michael III replied with an angry letter. It reportedly called Latin a barbarian tongue. Nicholas's answer in 865 was long and uncompromising. He said that Rome had a duty to defend a canonical bishop wherever he was. He also said some things about papal power that Eastern readers found hard to accept. Then the dispute over Bulgaria grew into a larger quarrel. In 867 Photius sent a letter to the Eastern bishops denouncing the Latin missionaries and some Western practices. A council he called in Constantinople declared Nicholas deposed.
Lotharingia. The king never fully gave in. In 865 Lothair promised to take Theutberga back, and he did, but he treated her cruelly. She later asked Rome to dissolve the marriage herself. Nicholas refused to treat her request as free, because it came from a woman who had been under pressure for years. Waldrada was summoned to Rome. The dispute dragged on, unfinished, until after Nicholas was dead.
He also made enemies by the way he did things. His letters were blunt. He addressed kings as a father would a disobedient son. Some of his contemporaries thought he overreached, and some modern readers still do. He did not fix every wrong, and some of the people he defended never saw justice.
The Last Weeks of the Pope Who Did Not Live to See the Ending
By the autumn of 867 Nicholas was ill. He had been pope for just over nine and a half years, and the work was still going. He dictated letters to the bishops of the Frankish kingdoms, asking them to answer Photius's accusations. He was still worrying about Bulgaria and the Lothair case.
He died in Rome on November 13, 867. There are no preserved last words, and it would be dishonest to supply any. We know he died in the city he served, still pope, still in conflict, with most of his questions unresolved.
He was buried in Saint Peter's Basilica. Within weeks, events in the East overtook the quarrel he had been fighting. In September 867 Emperor Michael III was murdered, and the new emperor, Basil I, removed Photius and restored Ignatius. In effect it was the verdict Nicholas had been demanding. He did not live to hear it.
What He Left Behind
Nicholas's immediate successors followed his course. Pope Hadrian II inherited the Lothair affair, and Lothair went to Rome in 869 to be reconciled and died on the way home. Boris of Bulgaria, disappointed by Rome after the 869–870 council in Constantinople assigned his Church to the East, expelled the Latin missionaries. Nicholas's Bulgarian mission did not last, though the humane advice he gave Boris stayed on the record.
What survived was the principle: the weak could appeal to Rome against the strong. A chronicler a generation after Nicholas wrote that since Pope Gregory the Great, nobody had compared to him. The Church has long honored him on November 13 and calls him Nicholas the Great. There was never a formal canonization process of the kind used today. The Roman Martyrology lists him as a saint.
His life points toward people he would plainly stand with. Those whose consent has been overridden. Spouses abandoned or slandered by those who should have loved them. Bishops and priests who suffer for appealing to the Church's law. New believers who need patient teaching, not pressure. And anyone who has to tell a powerful person that something is not theirs to decide.
Prayer
O God, shepherd of your people, you gave Pope Saint Nicholas the courage to stand before kings and the patience to teach new believers. Through his prayers, protect those who have been wronged by the powerful, strengthen those who defend the truth about marriage, and keep your Church united in faith and charity. Through Christ our Lord. Amen.
.jpg)
No comments:
Post a Comment