ALL SAINTS

 

The Great Schism (1054 AD): East vs. West

By the 11th century, Christianity had already weathered heresies and councils, but tensions simmered between its two power centers: Rome in the West and Constantinople in the East. The split wasn’t sudden—it brewed for centuries—but 1054 marks the breaking point.

Roots of Division

• Theological Drift: Small differences grew big. The West added “Filioque” (“and from the Son”) to the Nicene Creed, saying the Holy Spirit proceeds from both Father and Son. The East saw this as unauthorized tampering, insisting the Spirit proceeds only from the Father. It’s arcane but symbolic of deeper control issues.
• Authority Clash: Rome’s bishop (the Pope) claimed supremacy over all Christians, citing Peter’s primacy (Matthew 16:18). The East recognized Rome’s honor but saw the Patriarch of Constantinople as an equal among five key sees (Rome, Constantinople, Alexandria, Antioch, Jerusalem). Papal power grabs—like crowning Charlemagne emperor in 800—rankled the East.
• Cultural Gulf: The West spoke Latin, the East Greek. Rome’s feudal chaos contrasted with Byzantium’s centralized empire. Practices diverged: Western priests were celibate; Eastern ones married. The West used unleavened bread for the Eucharist; the East leavened. These piled up like kindling.

The Break: 1054

The flashpoint came when Pope Leo IX sent Cardinal Humbert to Constantinople to demand Patriarch Michael Cerularius recognize papal authority. Cerularius refused, criticizing Western innovations. On July 16, 1054, Humbert stormed into Hagia Sophia and slapped a bull of excommunication on the altar. Cerularius fired back, excommunicating the Pope. Both sides dug in.

Aftermath

The schism birthed two Churches:

• Roman Catholic Church (West): Centered in Rome, it leaned into papal monarchy, Latin liturgy, and doctrines like purgatory (formalized later).
• Eastern Orthodox Church (East): A federation of autocephalous (self-governing) churches under patriarchs, it kept Greek traditions, conciliar governance, and a mystical bent.

Was it final? Not technically—mutual excommunications were lifted in 1965—but the divide endures in theology, worship, and identity. The Triumphal Entry’s king now had two rival courts.

The Protestant Reformation (16th Century): Shattering the West

Fast-forward 500 years. The Western Church, now Roman Catholic, faced its own reckoning. Corruption, power, and theological unrest fueled a second great fracture.

Seeds of Revolt

• Corruption: By the 1500s, the Catholic Church was a juggernaut—wealthy, political, and often rotten. Popes like Alexander VI (a Borgia) flaunted mistresses and nepotism. Indulgences—paying to reduce time in purgatory—smacked of salvation-for-sale, especially with the 1517 push to fund St. Peter’s Basilica.
• Theological Stirrings: Renaissance humanism revived Scripture study. Erasmus’ Greek New Testament (1516) exposed flaws in the Latin Vulgate, nudging folks to question Church tradition. Medieval critics like John Wycliffe and Jan Hus had already challenged Rome’s authority, planting seeds.
• Political Backing: German princes, tired of papal taxes and meddling, saw a chance to break free. The printing press (Gutenberg, 1440s) spread dissent like wildfire.

The Spark: Martin Luther

On October 31, 1517, Martin Luther, a German monk, nailed (or mailed) his 95 Theses to the Wittenberg church door, blasting indulgences and calling for reform. He didn’t plan a schism—just debate—but Rome’s pushback radicalized him. Key ideas:

• Sola Scriptura: Scripture, not tradition or popes, is the ultimate authority.
• Sola Fide: Faith alone, not works or payments, justifies sinners before God.
• Priesthood of All Believers: No clergy monopoly—every Christian accesses God directly.

Excommunicated in 1521, Luther doubled down, translating the Bible into German. His ideas caught on, especially in northern Europe.

The Reformation Spreads

Others piled in:

• Ulrich Zwingli (Switzerland): Pushed a leaner liturgy, clashing with Luther over the Eucharist (real presence vs. symbolic).
• John Calvin (Geneva): Stressed God’s sovereignty and predestination, shaping Reformed theology. His Institutes (1536) became a Protestant playbook.
• Henry VIII (England): Broke with Rome in 1534 over his divorce, birthing the Anglican Church—less theological, more political.

Fallout: Denominations Multiply

The Reformation wasn’t tidy. By the late 16th century, Europe split:

• Lutherans: Dominant in Germany, Scandinavia.
• Reformed (Calvinists): Strong in Switzerland, Scotland, the Netherlands.
• Anglicans: England’s hybrid, blending Catholic and Protestant.
• Anabaptists: Radical fringe, rejecting infant baptism, persecuted by all.

The Catholic Counter-Reformation (Council of Trent, 1545-1563) fought back, clarifying doctrines and curbing abuses, but the West was fractured. Wars—like the Thirty Years’ War (1618-1648)—bled Europe over these divides.

Legacy of Division

The Great Schism and Reformation didn’t just split institutions; they birthed rival Christianities. Orthodoxy kept its ancient rhythms—icons, liturgy, mystery. Catholicism doubled down on tradition and hierarchy. Protestantism exploded into denominations—Lutheran, Presbyterian, Baptist, Methodist, and beyond—each claiming the Triumphal Entry’s king in its own voice.

. 

Related Post